The schooner Mogul had sunk off LBI on May 12, 1841, under mysterious circumstances; the captain and four crewmen had been seen abandoning the ship and rowing in the direction of Little Egg Inlet. A passing fishing boat came up to the Mogul. Its captain boarded it and reported he saw a body in the captain’s cabin and holes drilled in the ship’s side, which apparently had caused it to sink.

Once on shore at Little Egg Harbor, Mogul Capt. Daniel Snow and his mate left the rest of the crew and headed for…